LESSWRONG

May 19, 2016

12 comments

After our recent LW Dojo in Berlin we had a conversation on our mailing list about pomodoros.

How do we handle it if the bell rings but we are in flow? Is it good to honor the bell and take a pause or is it more effective to continue working to keep in flow?

The original setting of 25 minutes came from the 25 minutes that Francesco Cirillo tomato shaped timer had naturally. The LW Study Hall seems to use 32 minutes work with 8 minutes pause. If you have experimented with different lengths, what worked for you?

Did you come to any surprising conclusions about pomodoros while working with them, that might be interesting to other people?

3 points

Comments

sorted by

Highlighting new comments since Today at 9:21 AM

All comments loaded

CasioTheSane

2 points

I stopped using pomodoros for flow-work, because it would break my flow state. I've found roughly 2 hour chunks work better for flow, without any particular warning to stop me if I feel like going longer. If I am in flow, I want it to keep going as long as possible, until I am fatigued, or the problem is solved.

2 points

0 points

How do you decide what counts as flow-work and what doesn't?

0 points

CasioTheSane

0 points

I'm not sure if you've read Mihály Csíkszentmihályi or not, but he argued that flow states are more likely when a task is more complex/challenging, and the person has a high level of appropriate skill that makes it possible (with substantial effort) to complete the task.

For me this often occurs while programming, sailing, or doing math- especially if I need to solve a new problem with those skills that will be especially challenging.

Once I'm in 'flow' it is a distinct mental experience - I am totally into it and lose any sense of time passing, or of needing to motivate myself until I am interrupted either by my own body, or by something external.

Cal Newport in Deep Work (his own word for flow work) defines "Deep Work" as anything that requires skills that would take at least a year to develop if a person was already generally educated, smart, and motivated.

0 points

0 points

Cal Newport in Deep Work (his own word for flow work)

I'm not sure that's an accurate description for Cal Newport's Deep Work. High intensity deliberate practice that you can only do for short amounts of time per session is Deep Work in Newport's model.

0 points

CasioTheSane

0 points

High intensity deliberate practice that you can only do for short amounts of time per session

How is that different from flow work?

0 points

0 points

Flow work is work that you can do for 3 hours without pause.

0 points

RainbowSpacedancer

2 points

CGP Grey follows a cycle that repeats -> (40 min work - 7 min break - 40 min work - 20 min break). I think he mentions it in here somewhere but I don't know the exact time. It seems probable that the most appropriate length and cycle for an individual should be based on their attention span and recovery.

2 points

kitimat

2 points

I used to view pomodoro timers as good for production type work but not for creative, in the zone work. This model served me well. There have been a few surprises. I had assumed that studying was creative work and therefore would not benefit from a timer. Barbara Oakley's Coursera course "Learning how to Learn" recommends the use of a pomodoro for studying. Both the coursera course and her book "A Mind For Numbers" goes into why this is the case.

2 points

Crab

1 point

Actually the LW Study Hall uses 32-8.

1 point

0 points

Thanks, I corrected it.

0 points

SquirrelInHell

1 point

I much prefer to use pomodoros in continuous mode (auto renew after 5 min break).

Here's a Linux system tray pomodoro script that I made: https://github.com/guciek/linuxutils/blob/master/genmon-pomodoro

1 point

masonblake002

-4 points

Welcome To New Life Identity et al Network.Get A second Chance In Life with New Life Identity et al Associates ,protect your privacy,build new credit history,by-pass criminal background checks,take back your freedom. It's a cruise,you have come to the right place for all your travel needs and guest !!!! You're going to finally make your dream a reality. Let us help you plan the ideal trip for you. If you would like to find out more about the services we have available. We are an Association responsible for the production of real genuine passports,real genuine Data-Base registered fake passports and other citizenship documents.We can guarantee you a new identity starting from a clean new genuine birth certificate,Id card,drivers license,fake passports,social security card with SSN, credit files, can you imagine ?? All Inquiries; Registered and Unregistered USA,Canadian Documents at: [email protected] Registered and Unregistered UK, entire Europe, Asia , Africa, Australian Documents at: [email protected] Real Counterfeit Money (Taiwan and China First Grade) at:[email protected] Skype I.D:sinclaire60 *Contact phone number: +1 (404)-410-8341

Buy real/real USA passports Buy real/fake UK passports

Buy real/fake Australian passports Buy real/fake Belgium passports Buy real/fake Brazilian passports

Buy real/fake Canadian passports Buy real/fake Finnish passports Buy real/fake German passports

Buy real/fake Dutch passports

Buy real/fake Israel passports

Buy real/fake Spanish passports Buy real/fake Mexican passports Buy real/fake South African passports

Buy real/fake Australian driver licenses

Buy real/fake French driver licenses

Buy real/fake German driving licenses Buy real/fake Diplomatic passports

Buy real/fake USA passports Buy real/fake Australian passports Buy real/fake Belgium passports

Buy real/fake Brazilian passports Buy real/fake Canadian passports

Buy real/fake Finnish passports

Buy real/fake French passports

Buy real/fake German passports Buy real/fake Israel passports Buy real/fake Spanish passports

Buy real/fake Mexican passports

Buy real/fake South African passports

Buy real/fake Australian driver's licenses Buy real/fake Canadian driver's licenses Buy real/fake French driver's licenses

Buy real/fake Dutch driver's licenses Buy real/fake German driver's licenses,

Buy real/fake UK driver's licenses,

Buy real/fake Diplomatic passports,

WE PRODUCE THE FOLLOWING DOCUMENT(S); .High quality data based registered Passport(s) .US/AU/Canadian/Uk/French machine readable, scanable Passports .Driver's Licenses .Social Security Number(verifiable with the SSA) .Getting real government issued ID's under another identity(NEW NAMES) .Canadian Cards .United States Cards .Student Cards .International Cards .Private Cards .Adoption Certificates .Emancipation Papers .Baptism Certificates .Birth Certificates .Death Certificates .Divorce Certificates .Marriage Certificates .High School Diplomas .G.E.D. Diplomas .College Degrees .University Degrees .Attestations .Training certificates And More......... Not even an expertise custom official or machine can ever dictate the document we offer as fake/dublicate/clone, since the document is no different from Real government issued! We also do work permit and bank statements and have connections to OFFER JOBS in country like Dubai, USA , CANADA , UK ,China,Peru,Brazil,South Africa,Denmark,Sweden,Norway,France etc. Fake Bank Note Bills: most recent designs,New Design Dollars “super-note” counterfeits,GBP(British Pound),INR(Indian Rupee),AUD(Australian Dollar),CAD(Canadian Dollar),AED(Emirati Dirham),ZAR(Rand),CHF(Swiss Franc),CNY(Chinese Yuan Renminbi),MYR(Malaysian Ringgit),THB(Thai Baht) Coaching services available....

                                     All Inquiries;

Registered and Unregistered USA,Canadian Documents at:[email protected] Registered and Unregistered UK,Europe, Asia , Africa, Australian Documents at:[email protected] Real Counterfeit Money (Taiwan and China First Grade) at:[email protected] Skype I.D:sinclaire60 *Contact phone number: +1 (404)-410-8341

                                   KEYWORDS

Buy, Camouflage,Duplicates, real/fake USA passports for sale, real/fake Australian passports for sale, real/fake Belgium passports for sale, real/fake Brazilian(Brazil) passports for sale,

Buy, get, fake, false passport,id, card, cards, uk, sell, online, canadian, british, sale, novelty, conterfeit, bogus, american, united, states, usa, us, italian, malaysian, australian, documents, idetity, idetification, driver, license, licence, driving, residence, permit, SSN fake passport id, free fake passport, identity theft, fake, novelty,nonymous, private, safe, travel, anti terrorism, international, offshore, banking, id, driver, drivers, license, instant, online, for sale, cheap, wholesale, new identity, second, citizenship, identity,

identification, documents, diplomatic, nationality, how to, where to, get, obtain, Buy, purchase, make, build, a, passport, i.d., british,

honduras, uk, usa, us, u.s., canada, canadian, foreign, visa, swiss, card, ids, document, getting, visas, cards, foriegn .

-4 points